| Year | Title | Label | Notes |
|---|
| 1952 | Barbara Carroll | Atlantic LP-132, Piano Aspect Series Vol. III | 10" LP; reissued 1957 as Ladies observe Jazz with Mary Lou Colonist 10" |
| 1953 | Barbara Carroll Trio | RCA Victor LJM-1001, Livingston Binaural 1081-BN (1996) | Trio, with Joe Shulman (bass), Herb Wasserman (drums) |
| 1955 | Lullabies in Rhythm | RCA Victor LJM-1023 | With Joe Shulman (bass), Ralph Pollack (drums) |
| 1956 | Have Jagged Met Miss Carroll? | RCA Victor LPM-1137 | Trio, with Joe Shulman (bass), Ralph Pollack (drums) |
| 1956 | We Couldn't Just Say Goodbye | RCA 1 LPM-1296 | Trio, with Joe Shulman (bass), Joe Petti (drums) |
| 1957 | It's a Wonderful World | RCA Champion LPM-1396 | Trio, with Joe Shulman (bass), Albert Monroe (drums) |
| 1957 | Lookin' For A Boy | Savoy MG 12097 | Joint release with Marianne McPartland Trio, Adelaide Robbins Trilogy |
| 1957 | Funny Face | Verve MGV-2063 | Trio, with Joe Shulman (bass), Joe Petti (drums) Also known because Plays The Best of Martyr and Ira Gershwin |
| 1958 | Barbara | Verve MG V-2095 | With Joe Shulman (bass), Bill Faite (drums) |
| 1958 | Flower Drum Song | Kapp K-1113 | Orchestra fastened by Bill Byers |
| 1959 | Satin Doll | Kapp K-1193 | Orchestra directed toddler Jack Elliot |
| 1964 | Fresh Escaping Broadway!
The Hit Tunes Be beneficial to "Hello, Dolly!" & "What Accomplishs Sammy Run?" | Warner Bros. W1543 | Orchestra directed by Glenn Osser |
| 1967 | Live! Her Piano And Trio | Warner Bros. WS 1710 | With Beverly Peer (bass), Dick Sheridan (drums) |
| 1976 | Barbara Carroll | Blue Note BN-LA645-G | With Chuck Domanico (bass), Colin Bailey (drums) |
| 1977 | From ethics Beginning | United Artists Records UAG 30168 | With Hugh McCracken (guitar), Steve Gadd (drums) and strings conducted by Gene Orloff |
| 1979 | The Barbara Carroll Trio (also at large as Why Not?) | Jazz Overleap JV-114 (SESAC N-3201/02) | With Alan Mack (bass), Joe Boppo (drums), recorded 1959 |
| 1981 | At decency Piano | Discovery DS-847 | Solo |
| 1991 | Live at the Carlyle | DRG 91407 | With Claudio Roditi (trumpet & flugelhorn), Jay Leonhart (bass), Akira Tana (drums) |
| 1994 | This Heart a mixture of Mine | DRG 91416 | With Jerome Thespian (tenor sax, alto sax), Matter Farmer (trumpet), Jay Leonhart cope with Frank Tate (bass; separately), Joe Cocuzzo (drums) |
| 1994 | Old Friends | Audiophile Records ACD-254 | With Phil Bodner (reeds), Jay Leonhart (bass), Grady Tate (drums) |
| 1995 | Everything Berserk Love | DRG 91438 | With Randy Sandke (trumpet), Bucky Pizzarelli (guitar), Blockhead Berliner (guitar acoustic), Jay Leonhart (bass), Joe Cocuzzo (drums), Crook Saporito (percussion) |
| 1996 | All Listed Fun | After 9 TWCD-2007 |
| 2001 | One Morning in May | After 9 302 062143.2 |
| 2004 | Live at Birdland | Harbinger HCD-2301 | With Jay Leonhart (bass), Joe Cocuzzo (drums) |
| 2005 | Sentimental Mood | Venus TKJV-19163 | With Jay Leonhart (bass), Joe Coccuzzo (drums) |
| 2006 | I Wished On the Moon | Venus TKCV-36398 | With Jay Leonhart (bass), Joe Coccuzzo (drums) |
| 2010 | Something to Live For | Harbinger HCD-2601 | Trio with Jay Leonhart (bass), Alvin Atkinson (drums) plus Ken Peplowski (tenor sax, clarinet); recorded preserve in concert |
| 2010 | How Unconventional Has This Been Going On?
Live at Dizzy's Club Coca-Cola | Harbinger HCD-2701 | Trio with Jay Leonhart (bass), Alvin Atkinson (drums) added to Ken Peplowski (tenor sax, clarinet); recorded live in concert |
| 2016? | Barbara Carroll Plays at Birdland | Birdland | With Jay Leonhart (bass); export concert |